I saw something earlier this morning that made me… sad? Irritated? Disappointed?
Something. I'm still trying to figure out exactly what it was, although the longer I think about it, the more I suspect it was a little bit of all three.
But let me back up a bit.
I write a lot about the degradation of liberty in this country. The slow, relentless encroachment of government into our personal lives, almost always justified by some variation of the same tired argument: it's for our safety. If you've read more than a handful of my blogs, you've probably concluded that I'm pretty fucking obsessed with the subject. And you'd be right. I am.
I think about it constantly. About the intersection of government and our personal lives, and how those intersections have multiplied to the point that it's becoming increasingly difficult to find a single aspect of our existence that isn't regulated, monitored, taxed, licensed, restricted, or otherwise subject to somebody else's fucking permission. And when you sit back and consider all of those little intrusions in the aggregate, you start to realize something profoundly uncomfortable. We aren't nearly as free as we like to pretend we are. We're caged animals who occasionally get moved into a slightly larger enclosure, at which point we collectively throw our arms into the air and scream, "Freedom!" or "America!" as though somebody just handed us the keys to the kingdom.
Yeah. Whatever the fuck you say.
I'm down in Albuquerque right now. Spent the night here, and this morning I decided to go find myself a decent breakfast rather than subject myself to whatever questionable substances the hotel was passing off as sustenance. Besides, going out for breakfast meant starting my day with a ride, and if you know anything about me, you know that putting my ass on Nyx and twisting the throttle is a pretty fucking good way to start just about any day.
Now, I don't know exactly what Albuquerque's speed cameras look like, but I know the city has a bunch of them, and I'm reasonably certain I triggered a few on my way to breakfast. You see, my throttle hand doesn't always work quite right. Sometimes it twists a little farther than intended, and before I know it, I'm enjoying myself considerably more than the posted speed limit apparently permits.
Honest. Ain't kiddin' neither.
And before somebody starts clutching their pearls, let me save you the trouble. I've written about these cameras before, and my opinion hasn't changed. Albuquerque has structured its automated speed enforcement program around civil penalties rather than criminal traffic citations, and I have some pretty serious objections to the way that arrangement sidesteps the protections and standards we ordinarily associate with criminal proceedings. The city would undoubtedly argue that the program is lawful and serves a legitimate public safety purpose. I'm sure it has lawyers who can explain the entire thing in language sufficiently convoluted to make your fucking eyes bleed.
I see a government agency using cameras, vehicle registration records, and the machinery of civil enforcement to extract money from people who may never have interacted with an actual police officer. And I don't particularly care how many times somebody tells me it's for my own good. I've heard that argument before, and it usually ends with somebody reaching into my fucking wallet.
So no, I'm not particularly inclined to hand over money just because a camera and a computer have decided I owe it. If the city wants to pursue a citation, it can use whatever lawful process is available to it, and I'll make my decisions accordingly. But I'm not going to pretend I think the whole thing is some noble exercise in protecting the public.
Fuck that.
Anyway, believe it or not, the speed cameras aren't what pissed me off this morning. They're just part of the larger picture, because I've also written extensively about something else I believe is eating away at this country: the growing culture of entitlement, the erosion of personal responsibility, and the increasingly popular notion that somebody else should be obligated to provide whatever it is we don't feel like providing for ourselves.
I've had more arguments than I can count about government assistance, taxation, and the difference between voluntarily helping another human being and having the government compel that assistance under threat of punishment. My position has always been pretty straightforward. I believe in helping people. I believe in generosity. I believe in looking out for our neighbors, particularly when life has knocked them flat on their asses. What I don't believe is that the government should get to decide how generous I must be, reach into my paycheck, and redistribute the proceeds according to whatever political priorities happen to be fashionable this week.
There's a pretty fucking substantial difference between choosing to help somebody and being ordered to do it.
But there's another part of this conversation that doesn't get nearly enough attention, and that's the erosion of the everyday social expectations that once made living among other people a little more civilized. I'm talking about courtesy. Consideration. Manners. The little unwritten rules that nobody had to pass a fucking law to enforce because people understood that sharing a society meant occasionally thinking about somebody other than themselves.
And that's what I found myself thinking about this morning.
I walked into the restaurant and found myself waiting for a table with a bunch of other people. And I'm going to be a little catty here, because apparently that's the mood I'm in, and I don't particularly give a fuck.
A fair number of the people waiting looked like they'd rolled directly out of bed, stumbled into whatever clothing happened to be on the floor, and wandered into public without giving a moment's consideration to how they presented themselves. Some looked half drunk, half hungover, or otherwise still engaged in negotiations with whatever terrible decisions they'd made the night before. A few smelled like those negotiations weren't going particularly well.
And yeah, I noticed. Of course I fucking noticed.
But ultimately, that's their business. If somebody wants to go out looking like they lost a fight with a laundry basket, that's their prerogative. I might privately question their judgment, but I'm not interested in having the government establish a dress code for breakfast. That's the thing about actually believing in liberty. You don't get to support it only when other people make choices you happen to approve of.
People have the right to look ridiculous. They have the right to dress badly. They have the right to make choices I wouldn't make, and I have the right to think those choices are fucking stupid.
That's how this is supposed to work.
But how we treat one another? That's a different conversation.
When I'm waiting somewhere with limited seating, I generally stand. Unless there are plenty of empty chairs, I leave them available for people who might actually need them. Women carrying babies or wrangling young children. Elderly people. Someone with a cane, an injury, or a disability that makes standing difficult. It's not some grand act of sacrifice. I'm not expecting a fucking medal. It's just how I was raised.
You look around. You pay attention. You recognize that the world contains people other than yourself, and sometimes those people have needs that are a little more pressing than your desire to park your ass for five minutes.
And before somebody starts composing an indignant response about gender roles, let me clarify something. I'm not suggesting that women are incapable of standing or that men are somehow obligated to spend their lives hovering beside empty chairs. I'm saying that a parent trying to manage two small children might appreciate a seat more than I do. I'm saying that somebody who's spent eight decades on this planet might have knees that don't work as well as mine. I'm saying that if you're perfectly capable of standing comfortably for a few minutes, offering a chair to somebody who isn't should be about as controversial as holding a fucking door open.
It isn't complicated. Or at least it shouldn't be.
And yet, as I stood there waiting for breakfast, I watched three different men come into the restaurant. They weren't together. They arrived at different times, with different parties. All three appeared young, healthy, and perfectly capable of standing. And every single fucking one of them made a beeline for an empty chair the moment one became available.
Not one paused to look around. Not one seemed to consider whether somebody else might need it more. They saw an available seat, and their entire universe apparently contracted to the dimensions of their own fucking ass.
I actually shook my head. Physically. I couldn't help it.
And I doubt any of them noticed, because noticing would have required looking beyond themselves for a moment.
Now, to be fair, I don't know those men. I don't know whether any of them had an invisible disability, a medical condition, or some other reason for needing to sit. That's entirely possible, and I'm not pretending I can diagnose somebody's physical condition by looking at them across a restaurant lobby.
But what struck me wasn't simply that three men sat down. It was the complete absence of any visible consideration for the people around them. No hesitation. No glance around the room. No apparent recognition that an empty chair might represent something more than an opportunity to make themselves comfortable.
And yes, I realize we're talking about a fucking chair.
That's precisely the point.
Because I think the smallest behaviors often tell us something about the larger values we've either embraced or abandoned.
We live in a society where people will spend hours arguing about compassion, fairness, social responsibility, and how much money the government should take from one group of people to provide for another. I've had countless arguments with people who insist that government redistribution is a moral imperative, that opposing a particular spending program means you don't care about the poor, and that the measure of a compassionate society is how much assistance its government provides.
And every time, I come back to the same fundamental objection. You cannot measure your personal generosity by how enthusiastically you support spending somebody else's fucking money.
That's not generosity. That's a political preference.
Generosity is what happens when you give something up. When you sacrifice a little comfort, a little time, a little money, or a little convenience because somebody else needs it more than you do. It's voluntary. It's personal. And it requires recognizing another human being as something more than an abstract beneficiary of whatever program you happen to support.
Which brings me back to those chairs.
Giving up a seat costs almost nothing. No paperwork. No government agency. No tax increase. No bureaucratic eligibility determination. You don't have to fill out a fucking form or vote for somebody who promises to make everyone else do it.
You just stand up.
That's it.
And yet I can't help wondering how many people who passionately advocate for government-mandated compassion would fail to recognize an opportunity to practice the real thing when it's standing right in front of them.
I'm not suggesting those three men held any particular political beliefs. I have no fucking idea how they vote, whether they vote, or what they think about government assistance. For all I know, they're libertarians, conservatives, socialists, or completely uninterested in politics. Their political affiliations aren't the point.
The point is that we've become remarkably comfortable treating compassion as somebody else's responsibility.
We've built this enormous machinery of institutionalized assistance, wrapped it in the language of morality, and somehow convinced ourselves that supporting the machinery is an adequate substitute for personally giving a shit about the people around us.
And I think that's a dangerous trade.
Because once we outsource compassion to government, we begin to lose the habits that make compassion possible in the first place. We stop looking for opportunities to help because we've convinced ourselves that helping is somebody else's job. We stop seeing the elderly person standing beside us, the overwhelmed parent trying to juggle a toddler and a diaper bag, or the stranger who could use five minutes of consideration, because our attention is permanently fixed on whatever we happen to want at that particular moment.
We become experts at demanding generosity and amateurs at practicing it.
And the really fucked-up part is that we don't seem to recognize the contradiction.
We talk endlessly about rights, but increasingly little about responsibilities. We demand respect while showing precious little of it. We insist that society owes us consideration while behaving as though the people around us are little more than obstacles between us and whatever the fuck we're trying to get.
We want the benefits of civilization without the inconvenience of being civilized.
I don't know exactly when that happened. I don't know whether it was gradual, whether it accelerated with social media, whether it reflects changes in parenting, or whether every generation has looked at the next one and wondered what the fuck went wrong. Probably some combination of all of the above.
And I'm not going to pretend my generation was perfect. We weren't. We did plenty of stupid shit, and we've contributed more than our fair share to the mess we're living in now. Nor am I suggesting that every young person is an entitled asshole. I've met plenty who are thoughtful, hardworking, generous, and considerably more mature than people twice their age.
But I do think something important has been slipping away, and I don't think we should dismiss it simply because the evidence sometimes shows up in something as mundane as a restaurant waiting area.
Courtesy matters. Personal responsibility matters. Voluntary generosity matters. And the willingness to inconvenience yourself, even slightly, for another human being matters a hell of a lot more than we seem willing to admit.
I spend a great deal of time railing against the government for treating us like children who can't be trusted to manage our own lives. I resent the regulations, the surveillance, the endless attempts to protect us from ourselves, and the steady erosion of the individual liberty this country supposedly holds sacred.
But here's the uncomfortable question that this morning left rattling around in my head.
How the fuck are we supposed to preserve a free society if we can't be bothered to behave like responsible members of one?
Liberty requires more than demanding that the government leave us alone. It requires enough personal responsibility, restraint, and consideration that we don't need somebody standing over us with a fucking rulebook to tell us how to behave.
And no, I don't believe the government should legislate manners. I don't want a Department of Courtesy issuing citations because somebody failed to offer Grandma a chair. That would be precisely the kind of absurd government intrusion I've spent years writing against.
I want something considerably simpler.
I want people to give a shit.
Not because they're required to. Not because there's a penalty for failing to do so. Not because some politician has decided that kindness needs a fucking enforcement mechanism.
Because it's the right thing to do.
And because the freedom to make our own choices ought to come with at least a passing willingness to consider how those choices affect the people sharing the world with us.
Maybe that's what bothered me so much this morning. Not the three men. Not the chairs. Not even the general parade of people who apparently believe pajamas and questionable personal hygiene constitute acceptable breakfast attire.
It was the realization that, while I've been watching the government steadily consume more and more of our liberty in the name of protecting us, we've been surrendering something else entirely on our own.
Our sense of responsibility to one another.
We've traded liberty for the promise of safety, and somewhere along the way, we've started treating basic human decency as a service somebody else is supposed to provide.
And the saddest part is that no government forced us to make that second trade.
We did that all by our fucking selves.