If you've read my writing at all, you probably know how I feel about lawyers.
For those of you who haven't had that particular pleasure, allow me to clarify: I fucking hate what lawyers have done to this country.
I hate what they've done to our judicial system. I hate the way they've taken the protections enumerated in the United States Constitution and twisted them into something so convoluted that ordinary Americans are expected to hire one of these fuckers just to understand what their own government is legally permitted to do to them.
I hate that liberty, which was supposed to belong to the people, has become something government dispenses on a case-by-case basis, depending on which judge is sitting on the bench and which lawyer has the better argument.
And I particularly hate that the remarkably straightforward language of the Bill of Rights has been buried beneath two centuries of legal gymnastics until the words apparently mean whatever the fuck somebody in a black robe says they mean.
Take the First Amendment.
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
Pretty fucking straightforward, isn't it?
And yet, how many states have historically prohibited the sale of alcohol on Sundays because somebody decided their religious observances ought to govern everybody else's behavior?
What about the right of the people to peaceably assemble? Try organizing a sizable public gathering without first obtaining permission from some local government bureaucrat and see how far you get.
And freedom of speech? We've spent decades debating which expressions deserve protection, which ones are offensive enough to regulate, and when hateful motivations should increase criminal penalties. Murder is already illegal. Assault is already illegal. Why does government need to get into the business of deciding whether the thoughts in somebody's head make an already criminal act more criminal?
I could spend the next twenty pages discussing the liberties we've surrendered and the elaborate legal rationalizations used to justify taking them.
But I'm not going to. Because today I want to talk about something happening right here in Santa Fe, New Mexico: Automated traffic enforcement.
Speed cameras. Noise cameras. License plate readers. Automated surveillance systems that watch ordinary citizens going about their lives and turn their movements into opportunities for government enforcement.
And specifically, I want to talk about what happens when government decides it can sidestep constitutional protections simply by changing the fucking label on what it's doing.
Because Santa Fe has an ordinance.
And apparently we're all supposed to shut the fuck up because somebody at City Hall wrote it down.
Well, I've read the ordinance.
Now let's talk about the Constitution.
The Fourth Amendment: Leave Us the Fuck Alone
Here's what the Fourth Amendment actually says:
“The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”
Read that again.
Not somebody's interpretation of it. Not a summary from a law school textbook. Not a collection of Supreme Court opinions explaining why government ought to be allowed to do something the plain language seems designed to prevent.
The actual fucking words.
The right of the people to be secure.
It's interesting, isn't it, that protecting ordinary people from government intrusion was important enough to make it into the first ten amendments?
Anybody remember why?
I do.
Because the people who founded this country had firsthand experience with an oppressive government that treated its subjects as things to be searched, monitored, controlled, and punished.
British authorities used broad search powers, seized property, and enforced laws imposed by a government that the colonists increasingly regarded as illegitimate. General Thomas Gage and the Intolerable Acts became part of a much larger confrontation over the limits of government power.
Our founders weren't sitting around wondering how to make enforcement more efficient.
They were trying to make government less fucking dangerous.
Now imagine explaining modern Santa Fe to them.
We've got cameras watching vehicles. Devices reading license plates. Sensors measuring speed. Other sensors listening for noise. Computers collecting information and helping government decide who deserves a fine.
And we're supposed to believe the men who had just fought a revolution against intrusive government would have looked at this arrangement and said, “Well, that's a fine fucking idea. Why didn't we think of that?”
Give me a fucking break.
I know what the courts have said about reasonable expectations of privacy on public roads. I know lawyers have constructed elaborate distinctions between observing somebody in public and conducting a constitutionally prohibited search.
I know all of that.
And I think the entire fucking framework has lost sight of the principle the amendment was written to protect.
A government that can systematically monitor the movements of its citizens, identify their vehicles, record their activities, and turn those observations into financial penalties is exercising an extraordinary degree of power over people who have done nothing to harm another human being.
The fact that technology makes this possible doesn't make it acceptable.
And the fact that a court has approved some version of it doesn't make the underlying intrusion any less offensive to the concept of individual liberty.
The Fourth Amendment wasn't written to give government a convenient checklist for surveillance.
It was written to protect the fucking people.
The Fifth Amendment: Guilty Until You Pay
Now let's move on to the Fifth Amendment.
Among its protections are these:
“...nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law...”
Those words ought to mean something.
Especially that part about property.
Because my money is my fucking property.
And when government demands that I surrender some of it as punishment for an alleged violation, I expect more than a photograph, a computer-generated accusation, and instructions for how to pay.
Santa Fe's automated enforcement ordinance is particularly revealing.
Section 24-4.5(B) states: “The registered owner is strictly and vicariously liable for the violation unless one (1) of the exceptions herein applies.”
Read that carefully.
The registered owner.
Not necessarily the person driving.
Not necessarily the person who committed the alleged offense.
The person whose name happens to be associated with the fucking license plate.
And if the owner wasn't driving? The ordinance's nomination procedure expects them to identify who was.
So the city doesn't necessarily have to establish who was operating the vehicle before sending its demand for money. It starts with the owner and makes the owner deal with the consequences.
How fucking convenient.
The city calls this civil nuisance abatement.
I call it a deliberate inversion of the relationship between government and the people it supposedly serves.
Government is supposed to establish wrongdoing before imposing punishment. Instead, Santa Fe has created a system where an accusation arrives in the mail, financial liability attaches to vehicle ownership, and the recipient must take affirmative steps to contest it.
And if you don't respond within thirty-five days?
Section 24-4.5(E) says you're automatically in default, liable for the violation, barred from obtaining a hearing on its merits, and subject to an additional penalty.
Think about that.
A fucking computer-assisted enforcement system produces an accusation. A notice goes into the mail. And if you don't navigate the city's prescribed procedure quickly enough, you lose your opportunity to contest the underlying allegation.
That's an extraordinary amount of power to give a municipal bureaucracy.
Now, I can already hear the lawyers warming up.
“But there's an administrative hearing!”
Yes. I fucking know.
And under Section 24-4.5(F), the city's burden at that hearing is to establish the violation by a preponderance of the evidence.
Not beyond a reasonable doubt.
A preponderance.
And here's where this whole fucking arrangement gets particularly interesting.
Under New Mexico law, speeding is addressed by NMSA § 66-7-301, and § 66-8-116 identifies speeding violations as penalty assessment misdemeanors.
Misdemeanors. As in criminal offenses.
Now look at what Santa Fe has done.
Section 24-4.4(B) of its own ordinance incorporates violations of the city's existing speed-limit provisions into its automated enforcement program. Section 24-4.5(A) explicitly acknowledges that a police officer witnessing a traffic violation can issue a citation through ordinary traffic enforcement.
But photograph that same alleged conduct with a fucking camera?
Suddenly we're talking about a civil nuisance.
Not a criminal prosecution. Not the same burden of proof. Not the same constitutional protections.
Same fucking road. Same fucking speed limit. Same alleged violation.
But apparently, the moment a machine replaces a police officer, government gets to change the rules.
Think about the sheer fucking audacity of that.
The conduct didn't change. The speed limit didn't change. The supposed threat to public safety didn't change.
What changed was the government's obligation to prove its case.
And that's what makes this entire arrangement so fucking offensive.
Santa Fe has built an enforcement system that takes conduct already addressed by traffic law, routes it through a civil nuisance ordinance, attaches financial liability to the registered owner, and allows the city to prevail under a lower evidentiary standard.
All while assuring us that this is about public safety.
If the behavior is serious enough to justify government punishment, why the fuck should the constitutional protections surrounding that punishment depend on whether the accusation came from a police officer or a camera?
And if the city believes this is such an important public safety issue, why is it so fucking eager to pursue it through a process that makes enforcement easier for the government?
You don't get to make constitutional protections disappear simply by changing the fucking name of the proceeding.
And that's the heart of my objection.
Government gets to take conduct traditionally addressed through traffic enforcement, characterize its automated version as a civil nuisance, and proceed under a different set of rules.
And we're supposed to applaud this as innovation?
No.
We're supposed to question why government is so eager to build enforcement systems that don't require the same procedural protections as criminal prosecutions.
Yes, the ordinance provides for a hearing and an appeal to district court.
That doesn't end the argument. It begins it.
Because the question isn't merely whether the city has created a procedure.
The question is whether government should be permitted to construct this kind of enforcement machinery in the first fucking place.
And while we're at it, let's address something else: I don't believe every behavior government dislikes should automatically become a punishable offense.
There is a difference between conduct that actually harms another person and conduct that violates a rule some bureaucrat decided to write.
Speed alone doesn't tell the entire story of whether somebody is driving dangerously.
Context matters. Conditions matter. Actual behavior matters.
But context is inconvenient when your enforcement system consists of a sensor, a threshold, and a fucking invoice.
The state is not a person.
It doesn't have feelings.
It doesn't have a family.
And it doesn't get to claim the same moral standing as an actual human being who has suffered an actual injury.
Government exists because the people permit it to exist.
Somewhere along the way, the fucking government seems to have forgotten that.
The Sixth Amendment: Your Accuser Is a Fucking Camera
Now let's look at the Sixth Amendment.
“In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury...”
It goes on to protect the right to know the accusation, confront witnesses, obtain witnesses in one's defense, and have the assistance of counsel.
Those are not minor fucking technicalities.
They're protections against the enormous power of government.
But notice those first four words.
“In all criminal prosecutions.”
And there's the trick, isn't it?
Santa Fe's ordinance specifically declares its remedies civil rather than criminal.
Which means the city has designed an enforcement process that doesn't trigger the full protections guaranteed to someone facing criminal prosecution.
And somehow we're supposed to find that reassuring.
What bothers me is the ease with which government can take an alleged traffic violation, wrap it in the language of nuisance abatement, and move it into a system where the rules are more favorable to the government.
Your accuser is effectively an automated enforcement system.
A camera.
A sensor.
An algorithm.
A photograph of a license plate and a number recorded by a machine.
How the fuck do you confront a camera?
Are you supposed to put it on the witness stand?
“Excuse me, Your Honor, I'd like to ask the speed camera a few questions.”
What the fuck is it going to say?
Unless I've developed the ability to converse with inanimate objects, which would suggest an entirely different set of problems, I don't expect much of an answer.
Now, the city will tell you that the equipment's accuracy can be challenged. And its ordinance says that a respondent can challenge the weight or accuracy of the evidence.
Fine.
But it also declares that evidence collected by the automated system is authentic, is not hearsay, and shall be admitted.
That's an awfully friendly starting position for the government, isn't it?
The machine produces the evidence. The ordinance establishes its admissibility. The city pursues the fine.
And the citizen gets to fight uphill.
What about other drivers who witnessed the alleged violation? What about environmental conditions? What about equipment calibration, placement, maintenance, and the possibility of errors?
What about the simple proposition that government ought to be required to establish a person's wrongdoing through a process that doesn't begin by treating its own machinery as inherently trustworthy?
I want government to have to work to establish its accusations.
I want it to face scrutiny.
I want it to be uncomfortable when it exercises power over an individual.
That's the fucking point of constitutional protections.
They're not supposed to make government enforcement convenient.
They're supposed to make government tyranny difficult.
The Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments: More Government, More Fucking Process
Given the cost of living in Santa Fe, New Mexico, one could make a pretty colorful argument that any additional government fine is cruel and unusual punishment.
But I'm not going to spend much time on the Eighth Amendment.
I've got bigger fish to fry.
The Fourteenth Amendment, however, deserves a mention because it prohibits states from depriving people of life, liberty, or property without due process of law.
And that matters when the government taking your money is a city rather than the federal government.
Santa Fe doesn't get to escape constitutional scrutiny because its officials work at City Hall instead of in Washington, D.C.
The same fundamental question remains.
What protections are owed to an individual before government can punish them?
And how much of that protection can government dilute by calling its enforcement process civil?
Those are questions every citizen ought to be asking.
Not just the people who receive camera-generated tickets.
Because once you accept the principle that government can automate accusations and collect money through streamlined administrative machinery, why the fuck would you expect it to stop at speeding?
The Ninth Amendment: Liberty Doesn't Require a Fucking Permission Slip
Now we get to the amendment I think deserves a hell of a lot more attention.
The Ninth Amendment.
It's short enough that even a lawyer ought to be able to understand it:
“The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.”
There it is.
In plain fucking English.
The founders understood that they couldn't possibly list every liberty belonging to every human being.
And they didn't want future governments arguing that because a particular freedom wasn't explicitly written down, it didn't exist.
Yet that's precisely the kind of argument we've spent generations listening to.
Show me where the Constitution says you have that right.
Show me where the courts recognized it.
Show me the precedent.
Show me the statute.
How about you show me where the fuck government acquired the moral authority to interfere with peaceful people in the first place?
Because that's the question I think we've gotten backward.
Liberty shouldn't require permission.
Government power should require justification.
And two liberties that seem inseparable from the very concept of being a free human being are the right to move about and the right to privacy.
Think about that first one.
The right to move the fuck around.
What does freedom mean if you cannot travel from one place to another without government tracking you, monitoring you, or demanding that you justify your movements?
We have a word for people whose movements are controlled by an authority: Prisoners.
And prisoners, by definition, have been deprived of liberty.
I'm not suggesting a speed camera is literally the same thing as a prison cell.
I'm suggesting that a society in which government increasingly monitors ordinary movement is traveling in a direction that ought to make free people profoundly fucking uncomfortable.
You shouldn't have to explain where you're going.
You shouldn't have to justify why you're traveling.
You shouldn't have to wonder whether some government-operated device is recording your movements and adding another piece to a digital history of your life.
And you certainly shouldn't have to accept that arrangement simply because somebody says it's for your own safety.
Which brings me to privacy.
Privacy Isn't Something Government Gets to Grant
There's an interesting constitutional history surrounding the right to privacy.
And yes, I'm going to bring up Roe v. Wade.
Before somebody gets their political panties in a knot, let me make something perfectly fucking clear: I believe a woman has the right to make decisions about her own body.
Those decisions belong to her, in consultation with her doctor if she chooses, and not to a bunch of politicians who think their personal morality ought to dictate somebody else's medical care.
I don't give a fuck whether those politicians call themselves Republicans, Democrats, conservatives, liberals, or the Holy Order of People Who Can't Mind Their Own Fucking Business.
Stay out of it.
Now, I've long believed the constitutional reasoning used in Roe was unnecessarily complicated and vulnerable.
Not because I disagreed with protecting the underlying liberty.
But because I think the right to privacy is far more fundamental than the elaborate legal arguments constructed around it.
The Ninth Amendment should have been central to that conversation.
The people retain rights beyond those specifically enumerated.
And privacy is inseparable from liberty.
If I am not free to make personal decisions about my own life, my own body, my own home, and my own peaceful conduct without government interference, then what the fuck does freedom actually mean?
A right that exists only when government approves of how I exercise it isn't much of a right.
It's a privilege.
And privileges can be revoked.
That's not the country I believe our founders intended to create.
The American Revolution wasn't fought so future generations could build increasingly sophisticated systems for keeping tabs on one another.
It was fought, in significant part, because people had grown tired of being governed by an authority that treated their liberty as subordinate to its own demands.
And now here we are.
Hundreds of years later.
Building surveillance systems and calling them public safety.
Government Surveillance Is Not Fucking Progress
Let's put the pieces together.
The Fourth Amendment protects the people against unreasonable government intrusion.
The Fifth protects against deprivation of property without due process.
The Sixth establishes powerful protections for people accused in criminal proceedings.
The Fourteenth extends due-process protections against state and local government.
And the Ninth reminds us that the rights expressly listed in the Constitution aren't the only rights we possess.
Taken together, I see a constitutional philosophy built around one central proposition: Government is supposed to leave peaceful people the fuck alone.
Not monitor them by default.
Not build systems that automatically accuse them.
Not turn their movements into data points.
Not treat every technical violation as an opportunity to extract money.
And not hide behind administrative procedures whenever citizens demand meaningful protections against government power.
Santa Fe's automated enforcement program is a particularly ugly example of how far we've wandered from that principle.
The city declares speeding and excessive vehicle noise to be nuisances. It authorizes automated systems to detect alleged violations. It makes registered owners financially liable under its prescribed rules. It uses a civil standard of proof. And it distributes the revenue generated by the program according to the ordinance.
Read Section 24-4.6(D).
The city has written an entire mechanism for collecting and distributing the money.
Of course it fucking has.
There's always room in the budget for another mechanism to take money from people.
And when citizens object, the response is apparently to tell them to read the ordinance.
I've read it.
The ordinance is the fucking problem.
The fact that government has carefully documented the procedures by which it intends to exercise power doesn't settle whether that power is legitimate.
And it certainly doesn't settle whether citizens should tolerate it.
This is the distinction that seems to escape so many people who worship at the altar of government authority.
Legal is not synonymous with right.
A legislature can pass a law.
A city council can adopt an ordinance.
A court can issue an opinion.
None of those things makes government infallible.
And none of them should end a citizen's right to challenge the fundamental principles behind what government is doing.
The Fucking Bottom Line
I'm tired of watching government expand its reach while pretending that every new intrusion is a public service.
I'm tired of politicians invoking safety as though the word itself grants unlimited authority.
I'm tired of bureaucrats building systems that monitor ordinary citizens, accuse them of technical violations, and demand money.
And I'm particularly fucking tired of lawyers explaining why the protections written into our founding documents don't really mean what ordinary people think they mean.
I'm not interested in a government that promises to exercise surveillance responsibly.
I'm interested in a government that understands why it shouldn't be surveilling peaceful citizens in the first fucking place.
I'm not interested in making automated fines easier to pay.
I'm interested in asking why we have allowed government to make accusing and fining people so fucking easy.
And I'm not interested in being told that a city ordinance makes everything acceptable.
Because your fucking ordinance doesn't trump the Constitution.
Our rights don't originate at City Hall.
They don't originate in the state legislature.
They don't originate in the chambers of the Supreme Court.
They belong to us.
And government is supposed to protect them, not devise increasingly creative ways to work around them.
Santa Fe ought to be ashamed of how enthusiastically it's embracing automated surveillance and civil enforcement.
The legal profession ought to take a long, uncomfortable look at what happens when constitutional protections become exercises in technical interpretation rather than barriers against government power.
And to the nervous Nellies who believe every new camera is another wonderful step toward a safer society, perhaps another shot of whiskey and a little perspective would do you some fucking good.
Because the rest of us would like to live our lives without government peering over our shoulders, tracking our movements, and reaching into our wallets every time a computer decides we've misbehaved.
Liberty isn't a fucking nuisance.
Government intrusion is.
And it's about goddamn time we remembered the difference.