Apartment Number One

I want you to imagine something.

Pretend you live in a small apartment building. Ten units. Nothing particularly fancy. Just an ordinary building filled with ordinary people going about their ordinary lives. You live in apartment number one.

Upstairs, there's a young couple with a couple of kids. Neither of them seems to work. They're always outside smoking, usually with a kid perched on somebody's hip, and the husband seems pretty well fucking wasted by nine in the morning. You've tried talking to him a few times, but he's usually so far gone that having an intelligent conversation is about as productive as arguing with a fucking houseplant. So you've stopped trying. Now you just nod politely, keep walking, and mutter something like "fuck that guy" under your breath once you're out of earshot.

You feel sorry for the kids, though. Because whatever the hell their parents are doing, those kids didn't ask to be born into it. You wonder how the family manages to pay rent. Or electricity. Or buy groceries. They don't even have a car. And as far as you can tell, neither parent has any particular interest in changing their circumstances.

Down the hall lives an elderly gentleman. Nice guy. Always pleasant. Always has something friendly to say when you pass him in the hallway. Every morning, he heads out for breakfast at his favorite little restaurant. You figure he's retired. Probably worked most of his life, saved what he could, and now lives on whatever retirement income he's managed to put together. He's got an old Subaru. Thing's probably twenty years old, but it runs like a fucking top. He takes care of it. Just like he apparently takes care of everything else.

And then there's you. You're not rich. Hell, you're not even particularly comfortable. But you get by. You've been getting up and going to work every morning for thirty fucking years. Out the door by seven. Lunch packed in a little bag because buying lunch every day is an unnecessary expense you can't really justify. You put in your hours, come home, and spend whatever's left of your day doing the things that make life worth living. Maybe you've got a hobby. Maybe you like cooking. Maybe you just want to sit on your ass and watch television for a couple of hours before doing it all over again tomorrow. Whatever. It's your life. And you've worked pretty fucking hard to build it.

Now, every once in a while, you notice the landlord stopping by the upstairs apartment. Usually around the seventh of the month. You figure he's looking for rent. Because, you know, that's generally how apartment buildings work. People live in them. People pay rent. And landlords use that money to pay the mortgage, maintain the property, cover expenses, and hopefully make a little money themselves. Pretty straightforward arrangement.

Until somebody new moves into apartment number four.

She's barely unpacked before she notices the landlord knocking on the upstairs couple's door. And holy fucking shit. She's outraged. How dare he? Can't he see these people are struggling? They have children, for fuck's sake! Where's his compassion? Where's his humanity? Live and let live!

The landlord patiently explains that he has a mortgage to pay. Property taxes. Insurance. Maintenance. Repairs. And, believe it or not, he'd also like to make enough money from the property to justify owning the fucking thing. But apartment number four isn't interested in hearing any of that. She's interested in justice. Or at least her particular interpretation of it. And she's decided that the young couple upstairs shouldn't have to worry about paying their rent.

Wonderful. How compassionate. How generous. How extraordinarily fucking noble.

Except there's a problem. She doesn't intend to pay their rent herself. Nope. Instead, she marches down the hallway and starts pounding on your door. You answer. And she informs you that you need to start contributing money every month to help cover the upstairs couple's rent.

Excuse me?

Yes, she explains. They're struggling. They have children. They need help. And you have a job. You have an income. You're clearly doing better than they are. Therefore, you should help.

Now, you're standing there in your doorway, looking at this woman you've known for approximately fifteen fucking minutes, wondering whether you've somehow wandered into an alternate universe. Because you already have rent to pay. And groceries to buy. And a car to maintain. And bills of your own. You've spent thirty years getting up every morning, going to work, and making the sacrifices necessary to support yourself. Meanwhile, the guy upstairs is usually halfway through his morning buzz before you've finished your first cup of coffee. And now somebody is demanding that you subsidize his lifestyle.

Not asking. Demanding. Because apparently your ability to support yourself has created an obligation to support him, too. And if you object? Well, obviously you're selfish. Greedy. Uncompassionate. Probably a terrible fucking person. After all, there are children involved.

And that's where things get complicated. Because you do feel sorry for those kids. Of course you do. They didn't choose their parents. They didn't choose their circumstances. And they certainly shouldn't have to suffer because the adults responsible for them can't seem to get their shit together.

Maybe you'd be willing to help. Maybe you'd buy groceries. Maybe you'd contribute to a fund that made sure the kids had clothes, school supplies, and enough food to eat. Hell, maybe you'd even help the parents find work. But there's a difference between helping somebody get back on their feet and being expected to carry them indefinitely. And there's a pretty substantial difference between voluntarily helping your neighbors and having another neighbor decide how much of your paycheck she's entitled to redistribute. Especially when she seems considerably more interested in spending your money than addressing the circumstances that created the problem in the first place.

And what about the elderly gentleman down the hall? What happens if his retirement income isn't enough? What happens if his Subaru finally gives up the ghost? What happens if he gets sick? He's spent his life working. Shouldn't that count for something? Or are we simply going to look at everyone's circumstances, decide who has more than somebody else, and start moving money around until apartment number four feels sufficiently virtuous?

And here's another question. What happens when you lose your job? Who's going to pay your rent? The woman in apartment number four? The couple upstairs? Or are you suddenly going to discover that the generosity everybody was so enthusiastic about depended entirely on your continued ability to fucking work?

Now, obviously, this is a hypothetical. And yes, I've deliberately made the upstairs couple particularly unsympathetic. Because I want you to think about something. Not everybody who needs help is lazy. Not everybody receiving assistance is taking advantage of the system. People get sick. People lose jobs. People suffer injuries. People find themselves in circumstances they never imagined, through absolutely no fault of their own. I fucking understand that. And I believe there's a place for helping people who genuinely need help.

But I also believe there's a difference between a safety net and a hammock. And somewhere along the way, we've become remarkably uncomfortable acknowledging that distinction. We've created a political environment where questioning how assistance is distributed is frequently treated as questioning whether assistance should exist at all. Those are not the same fucking question.

Neither is questioning whether government should be allowed to collect taxes. Of course government needs revenue. Roads don't build themselves. Emergency services don't operate on good intentions. National defense isn't free. And a functioning society requires some degree of shared investment. I'm not arguing otherwise.

What I'm questioning is the assumption that somebody else's need automatically establishes an unlimited claim on the fruits of your labor. Or that the existence of a problem necessarily means government should be given more money to solve it. Especially when government has demonstrated a remarkable ability to spend enormous amounts of money without necessarily producing results proportional to the expense.

And then, when the results fall short? Well, obviously, the problem is that we haven't given it enough fucking money. So we need more taxes. More programs. More administration. More people whose jobs involve deciding how much money should be taken from one group of people and distributed to another.

And if you object? You're selfish. You're greedy. You don't care about poor people. You don't care about children. You don't care about society.

Bullshit.

I can care about people without agreeing that every problem should be solved by reaching into somebody else's fucking pocket.

Here's what bothers me. We've become so accustomed to talking about government spending in terms of abstract numbers that we sometimes forget where the money comes from. People. Actual fucking people. People who get up every morning and go to work. People who sacrifice. People who save. People who take risks. People who build businesses. People who spend decades making decisions about how to support themselves and their families.

And yes, some of those people become extraordinarily successful. Good for them. That doesn't mean they have no obligations to the society in which they prospered. But neither does it mean their success should be treated as a bottomless fucking checking account.

And I think we've become far too comfortable with the idea that generosity is something we demonstrate by demanding that somebody else pay for it. It's easy to be compassionate with money you didn't earn. It's easy to promise solutions when somebody else is expected to finance them. And it's especially easy to condemn the person being handed the bill when they have the audacity to ask what the fuck they're paying for.

So let's go back to that apartment building. You're standing in the doorway of apartment number one. You've just gotten home from another long day at work. You're tired. You've got your own bills to pay. And standing in front of you is a woman you've barely met, demanding that you subsidize the rent of somebody who, as far as you can tell, isn't making much effort to support himself.

She tells you it's the compassionate thing to do. The fair thing. The morally correct thing. And if you refuse, you're a selfish bastard.

So I'm asking. How would you feel? Would you open your wallet? Would you tell her to fuck off? Or would you ask why the hell she's standing at your door instead of upstairs, trying to help that family find a way to support itself?

Because that's the conversation I think we ought to be having. Not whether people deserve compassion. They do. Not whether society should help people who genuinely need it. It should. But whether compassion should be measured by how much of somebody else's money we're willing to spend. And whether the people demanding that generosity have any responsibility to make sure it actually accomplishes something.

Because I'm getting pretty fucking tired of people pounding on apartment number one's door.

Especially when they never seem particularly interested in paying the fucking rent themselves.

Next
Next

The Qualified Idiot