Years ago, I was remodeling the house I owned with my wife at the time. And part of that remodel involved installing a skylight in the kitchen.

A fucking big one.

Thing was about three feet square, give or take.

Now, installing a skylight naturally requires cutting a hole in the fucking roof. So I grabbed my Sawzall, climbed up there, and started cutting.

And then I smelled gas.

Well, that's fucking weird.

I stopped immediately. I know the signs of danger, and smelling natural gas while cutting through a roof is a pretty fucking good one.

As soon as the saw stopped, I heard it.

Hissing.

Fuck.

There was a gas line buried between layers of roofing.

Yeah. Welcome to Santa Fe-style construction, where everybody and their goddamned brother has worked on your house at some point, using whatever materials, techniques, and questionable engineering practices happened to strike their fancy that afternoon.

Apparently, somebody had decided that running a gas line up to the roof, across it, and back down was a perfectly reasonable thing to do.

And then somebody else decided to bury that gas line beneath another layer of roofing.

Brilliant.

But I'd been dealing with this kind of shit for two years as we methodically remodeled damn near every room in that house. So I shut off the gas, assessed the situation, and figured that since I was already going to have to repair the fucking gas line, I might as well finish cutting the hole.

Which I did.

Now, here's where this story gets interesting.

A friend and her husband had stopped by to visit. And, in fairness, I should mention that I'd served with her husband aboard a submarine. That's actually how I'd become friends with his wife.

While I was cutting this enormous hole in my roof, he apparently made a comment to my then-wife about how ballsy it was.

Ballsy.

To cut a hole in a roof.

And for some reason, that comment has stuck with me all these years.

Because what he saw as courage, I saw as a necessary step in completing a project.

It's a fucking house. Built by humans.

I'd seen skylights in other houses. I knew what a skylight was supposed to accomplish. And I was reasonably certain that installing one would require removing the drywall, rafters, roofing materials, and apparently the occasional fucking gas line standing between the sunlight and my kitchen.

Turns out I was right.

Imagine that.

But what stuck with me wasn't the skylight. Or the gas line. Or even the spectacular collection of questionable decisions made by previous owners of that house.

It was his fear.

Fear of doing something because he didn't know how to do it.

And I think that particular fear has become one of the defining characteristics of modern American society.

We've become so fucking specialized that we've forgotten how to just do things.

And worse, we've built entire industries around making sure nobody else is allowed to.

 

The Referral Economy

Take healthcare.

Years ago, I could go to my dentist with a problem, and my dentist would generally fix the fucking problem.

Now?

The dentist looks at it, nods thoughtfully, and says, "Yep. That needs work."

And hands me a referral.

Apparently, I need somebody who specializes in that particular variety of dental misery.

So now I've got two appointments, two offices, two sets of paperwork, and two fucking bills.

Sometimes three.

It's brilliant, really. From a racketeering perspective.

As a consumer, it's annoying as fuck.

And before somebody starts lecturing me about the importance of specialized medical knowledge, I get it. There are procedures that absolutely require specialized training, equipment, and experience.

I'm not suggesting that the receptionist at my dentist's office should perform reconstructive jaw surgery between answering phone calls.

But somewhere along the way, we've created a system where the ability to recognize a problem and the authority to fix that problem have become two entirely separate commodities.

And I've experienced that firsthand.

After my motorcycle accident, I developed a Morel-Lavallée lesion on my left thigh.

For those unfamiliar with the term, it's a collection of fluid that develops when traumatic forces separate layers of tissue beneath the skin.

Basically, I had a big fucking fluid-filled pocket in my leg.

I knew what it was.

I fucking diagnosed it myself.

But finding a doctor willing to actually diagnose it, much less do something about it, turned into a goddamned odyssey.

Doctor after doctor glanced at it and assured me it would reabsorb.

Except it wasn't reabsorbing.

And it didn't.

It took me three fucking months to find somebody willing to take the problem seriously and give it a proper diagnosis.

But that doctor couldn't simply drain the thing.

Nope.

That required a specialist.

And the specialist needed an MRI.

But I have an implanted defibrillator, which meant I couldn't simply stroll into the usual MRI appointment. I needed a facility with the appropriate equipment and protocols.

And naturally, the person qualified to handle that particular arrangement was unavailable until the following week.

Eventually, I got the MRI.

Which confirmed what I'd already known.

And what the doctor who finally listened to me had already diagnosed.

But now we needed to schedule surgery.

With another specialist.

Who possessed the particular qualifications necessary to stick a needle into a large, fluid-filled pocket in my thigh and drain the fucking thing.

Seven months.

Seven fucking months to resolve a problem that, thirty years ago, I suspect would have been handled in a doctor's office with considerably less ceremony.

And yes, I understand that these lesions can be complicated, that some require surgery, and that sticking needles into things without understanding the underlying anatomy can create serious problems.

I understand all of that.

I also understand that I spent months being shuffled through a system that seemed considerably more efficient at generating appointments than resolving the problem.

Five billing opportunities.

Seven months.

One fucking leg.

 

When Fixing Things Was the Job

Before I came to the laboratory, I worked as a maintenance technician in food packaging and manufacturing plants.

My job was pretty straightforward.

Keep the equipment running.

Because the equipment made the company money.

And when the equipment stopped running, the company stopped making money.

So when something broke, we fucking fixed it.

Electrical problem? Fix it.

Mechanical problem? Fix it.

Pneumatic system? Hydraulic system? Boiler? Conveyor? Packaging machine?

Figure out what's wrong and fix the motherfucker.

I remember one time we had a problem with the main boiler at a dairy packaging plant.

Part of the refractory material that shaped the flame and directed heat transfer inside the boiler had deteriorated.

So we shut the boiler down, made it safe to enter, and I climbed inside the fucking thing.

We rebuilt the damaged section using fiberglass-reinforced refractory material, got everything back together, and returned the boiler to service.

The entire evolution took about half a day.

No manufacturer flying in a specialist from three states away.

No four-month planning committee.

No parade of consultants explaining why the problem was far too complicated for the people who actually maintained the equipment.

We identified the problem.

We fixed the problem.

And we got back to work.

Imagine that.

 

Qualified to Talk About Qualifications

Which brings me to the other day.

I was sitting in a meeting at work, surrounded by maintenance management professionals, including a training representative.

And the subject of conversation was "qualified electrical workers."

Holy fucking hell.

What a shit show.

I sat there listening to people discuss who should be qualified to work on electrical equipment.

People who, in some cases, had never actually worked on electrical equipment themselves.

But they were discussing qualifications.

And training requirements.

And who should be authorized to do what.

You know.

To keep the workers safe.

Now, don't misunderstand me. Electrical safety is important. Electricity can kill you, and it generally doesn't give a flying fuck how many years of experience you have when it does.

But listening to people who have never done the work determine who should be allowed to do the work is an experience that tests the limits of my patience.

Especially considering my background.

Right out of high school, I went through the Navy's nuclear power training program.

But before I even got to nuclear power school, I attended Electronics Technician "A" School.

AC circuits. DC circuits. Boolean algebra. Semiconductors. Motor theory. Electrical fundamentals.

The whole fucking nine.

Then came nuclear power school, where we studied electrical, mechanical, and nuclear engineering principles, water chemistry, heat transfer, fluid flow, and all the other wonderful things you need to understand when somebody decides to put a nuclear reactor inside a steel tube and send it underwater.

And when I got to the submarine?

Guess what?

We operated the nuclear power plant.

And maintained it.

And troubleshot the instrumentation and electrical equipment that supported its operation.

We weren't standing around waiting for a specialist to arrive every time something stopped working.

We were the fucking specialists.

And we had to understand how the entire system worked, because when something went wrong, there wasn't exactly a convenient service center down the street.

I remember one incident at sea when an instrumentation problem caused a reactor shutdown.

Now, for those unfamiliar with submarine operations, having your reactor shut down while you're out in the ocean is not exactly an ideal situation.

You're suddenly sitting there, unable to operate the way a nuclear submarine is intended to operate.

Which is underwater.

Preferably moving.

Instead, you're bobbing around like a fucking cork, wondering whether somebody who doesn't particularly like Americans might notice.

So getting that reactor back online was a fairly high priority.

We were troubleshooting the instrumentation, and my chief decided he wanted to help.

He wasn't particularly strong when it came to electrical circuits, but he was the chief.

And chiefs, apparently, are required to contribute something.

So he told me to check a particular capacitor.

I explained that if that capacitor had failed, the circuit would exhibit an entirely different set of symptoms than the ones we were seeing.

In other words, checking it would be a waste of fucking time.

I knew what I was looking at.

I understood the circuit.

And I needed him to leave me the fuck alone so I could fix it.

But he was the chief.

So he ordered me to check the capacitor.

And when I challenged the usefulness of that particular exercise, his pride got hurt.

Which meant we wasted valuable time checking something that had nothing to do with the problem.

Because authority had temporarily become more important than expertise.

And that, right there, is exactly what I think about when I hear people who've never worked on electrical equipment debating who should be qualified to work on electrical equipment.

The people who understand the work are no longer necessarily the people making the decisions.

 

The Experts in Expertise

And then there's the training industry.

In the Navy, we handled much of our own training.

The people who operated and maintained the equipment trained the people who would eventually operate and maintain that same equipment.

What a fucking concept.

Now we've created entire layers of professionals whose job is to determine what training other professionals need before they're allowed to perform work those professionals may have been doing for decades.

And I'm not suggesting that training is unnecessary.

Quite the opposite.

Training is essential.

But we've confused the administration of training with the possession of expertise.

We've created specialists who specialize in deciding whether other specialists are sufficiently specialized.

And somewhere in that bureaucratic circle jerk, the actual work becomes almost incidental.

It's not just maintenance.

Look at automotive repair.

Once upon a time, you took your car to a mechanic.

Now, good luck finding somebody who understands the entire fucking vehicle.

You've got transmission specialists, electrical specialists, diagnostic specialists, and technicians who apparently need permission from a computer before they're allowed to turn a wrench.

Or home repairs.

Need something fixed in your house?

Don't call a carpenter.

You need a drywall contractor who specializes in a particular finish, followed by a painter who specializes in a particular coating, followed by somebody else who specializes in explaining why neither of them is responsible for the fucking crack that appeared three weeks later.

And healthcare?

Jesus Christ.

We've already covered that particular circus.

 

The Cost of Being Afraid

Here's what I keep coming back to.

That skylight.

And the man who thought cutting a hole in my roof was an act of extraordinary courage.

It wasn't.

I wasn't fearless. I wasn't particularly brave. And I certainly wasn't pretending that cutting into a roof couldn't create problems.

Hell, I found a fucking gas line.

But I understood that accomplishing something generally requires doing something.

And if you don't know how to do it, you figure it out.

You learn.

You ask questions.

You study the problem.

You develop the skills.

And then you fucking do it.

Somewhere along the way, I think we've lost confidence in that process.

We've become afraid of doing things outside the narrow boundaries of our assigned expertise.

And instead of encouraging people to expand those boundaries, we've built systems that reinforce them.

More credentials.

More certifications.

More approvals.

More referrals.

More people whose job is to tell other people whether they're allowed to do their jobs.

All supposedly in the name of safety, quality, and professionalism.

And sometimes those requirements are absolutely justified.

But sometimes they're just bureaucracy masquerading as expertise.

I'm not arguing that specialization has no value. Of course it does. Modern technology, medicine, and engineering would be impossible without people who possess extraordinarily deep knowledge of particular subjects.

But deep knowledge of one thing shouldn't require complete ignorance of everything surrounding it.

And having a credential doesn't automatically mean somebody understands the fucking system.

We've spent decades turning generalists into specialists, specialists into subspecialists, and subspecialists into people who apparently can't accomplish anything without consulting three other subspecialists.

Meanwhile, the people who actually know how to fix things are increasingly buried beneath layers of administrative oversight.

And I wonder how much of that started with fear.

Fear of making a mistake.

Fear of taking responsibility.

Fear of doing something that somebody else might be better qualified to do.

Fear of cutting a fucking hole in the roof.

Because at some point, somebody has to pick up the Sawzall.

And actually do the fucking work.

Next
Next

ICE, ICE Baby