Maybe It’s Time to Abolish the Fucking Speed Limit

All this talk about speed cameras, noise sensors, automated enforcement, and government finding increasingly creative ways to reach into our fucking wallets has gotten me thinking about something else.

Speed limits.

Specifically, why the fuck do we still have so many of them?

Now, before somebody gets their panties in a knot and starts screaming about public safety, let me explain where I'm going with this.

Because I think we've reached a point where the technology in our vehicles has advanced so dramatically that it's worth asking whether the rules governing how we operate them have kept up.

And I'm not convinced they have.

Fifty Years of Progress, Except for the Fucking Speed Limit

Let's start with a little history.

Back in 1973, the United States found itself in the middle of an energy crisis following an oil embargo by Arab oil-producing nations. Gasoline prices skyrocketed, shortages became a reality, and Americans found themselves waiting in lines at gas stations.

The federal government's response included the National Maximum Speed Limit, signed into law by President Richard Nixon in 1974.

Fifty-five miles per hour.

On highways.

Across the entire fucking country.

The idea was to conserve fuel by reducing the speed at which Americans traveled.

And while the government eventually loosened those restrictions, first allowing higher limits on certain rural interstates and ultimately repealing the national maximum in 1995, the entire episode illustrates something I find particularly offensive.

The federal government had to give the states back the authority to determine their own highway speed limits.

Give it back.

Think about that for a moment.

Our system of government was designed around limited federal authority, with powers not delegated to Washington reserved to the states and the people.

Yet somehow, we'd arrived at a place where Washington was dictating how fast people could drive on highways across the country, and the states had to wait for federal permission to make their own decisions.

My, how fucking times have changed.

Anyway, back to the speed limit. 

These Aren't Your Grandfather's Fucking Cars

Think about the vehicles Americans were driving when that national speed limit was introduced.

Big, heavy cars with comparatively primitive suspension systems, braking technology, tires, and steering.

Some were magnificent machines. Some were absolute pieces of shit. And some managed to be both simultaneously.

But compare them with what we're driving today.

Modern vehicles have sophisticated suspension systems, electronic stability control, traction control, anti-lock brakes, advanced tire compounds, and steering systems that make controlling a vehicle easier and more predictable.

Front-wheel drive and all-wheel drive are commonplace.

Our tires are better. Our brakes are better. Our roads and vehicle lighting have improved in countless ways.

Hell, even our windshield wipers are better. You can actually see out of the fucking windshield in a rainstorm without having to rely entirely on divine intervention.

And then there's occupant protection.

Crumple zones. Airbags. Seatbelts. Reinforced passenger compartments. Side-impact protection.

Cars are designed to absorb and manage crash energy in ways that would have seemed extraordinary fifty years ago.

We've also added an entire collection of technologies intended to help drivers avoid collisions in the first place.

Blind-spot monitoring. Lane-departure warnings. Automatic emergency braking. Adaptive cruise control. Rear-facing cameras.

Some vehicles can practically park their fucking selves.

Now, I'm not suggesting any of these technologies make a driver invincible. Physics still exists, and crashing into something at eighty miles per hour is considerably more consequential than doing so at forty.

But these are not the same vehicles we were driving in 1974.

Not even fucking close.

And while vehicle technology has advanced, we're still arguing about whether somebody traveling seventy-five miles per hour on an open interstate is a dangerous criminal because a sign says sixty-five.

Really?

A Number on a Sign Doesn't Tell the Whole Fucking Story

Here's what bothers me.

We've become so accustomed to treating speed limits as unquestionable that we've almost stopped asking what they're supposed to accomplish.

Is the objective to prevent dangerous driving?

Or is the objective to ensure that everybody obeys a number?

Because those are not necessarily the same fucking thing.

Consider two drivers.

One is traveling eighty miles per hour on a dry, nearly empty interstate in a modern, well-maintained vehicle, paying attention to the road and maintaining a safe distance from other traffic.

The other is traveling fifty-five miles per hour in a blinding rainstorm, tailgating the vehicle ahead, distracted by a phone, and riding around on tires that should have been replaced six months ago.

Which one is driving dangerously?

If your answer is automatically the person traveling eighty, I'd suggest you haven't thought very hard about the question.

Speed matters. Of course it fucking matters.

Higher speeds reduce reaction time, increase stopping distance, and make collisions more violent.

But speed is only one component of driving safety.

Road conditions matter. Visibility matters. Traffic density matters. Vehicle condition matters. Driver attention and judgment matter.

And yet, government has built an enforcement system that often reduces all those considerations to a single question:

Were you traveling faster than the number on the fucking sign?

If yes, congratulations. You're now an opportunity for revenue collection.

What If We Just Got Rid of Them?

Now here's where I'm really going to upset some people.

What if we abolished speed limits?

Not necessarily everywhere. I'm perfectly willing to have a conversation about school zones, crowded residential streets, and other places where pedestrians and vulnerable road users create fundamentally different risks.

But on major highways?

Why the fuck not?

We already have laws addressing reckless driving, careless driving, impaired driving, and conduct that endangers other people.

Those mechanisms already exist.

So why do we need another layer of enforcement based primarily on whether a driver exceeded a predetermined number?

Why not concentrate on actual dangerous behavior?

Tailgating. Aggressive weaving through traffic. Driving too fast for weather or road conditions. Operating an unsafe vehicle. Driving while distracted or impaired.

Those are behaviors that can put other people at risk regardless of whether somebody is traveling above or below the posted limit.

And before somebody says that eliminating speed limits would turn every highway into a demolition derby, consider that Germany has stretches of its Autobahn without a general speed limit.

It's not an unrestricted free-for-all. There are still rules, speed restrictions in particular areas, and serious expectations about how drivers behave.

But the concept of a highway without a universal numerical speed limit is hardly some impossible fantasy.

It exists.

And civilization hasn't fucking collapsed.

I'm not saying we should copy Germany wholesale. I'm saying that maybe, just maybe, we ought to question the assumption that every stretch of highway requires government to dictate a maximum speed regardless of conditions.

At the very least, shouldn't we be reevaluating those numbers in light of modern vehicle capabilities, road engineering, and actual safety data?

Because blindly preserving a rule simply because it's been around for decades is a pretty fucking lousy justification for keeping it.

But What About the Revenue?

Ah, yes.

The money.

Because there's another reason I suspect government isn't particularly enthusiastic about eliminating speed limits.

Traffic enforcement generates revenue.

And once government develops a reliable way to collect money, it becomes remarkably reluctant to surrender it.

Now we're installing cameras and sensors that can automatically detect alleged violations, identify registered vehicle owners, and generate notices demanding payment.

No officer needs to pull you over.

No human being necessarily needs to witness the alleged conduct.

The system just keeps operating.

Day after day.

Photograph. Process. Invoice.

And we're supposed to celebrate this as progress.

I don't believe government programs should be designed around their ability to fund themselves through penalties imposed on the people they're supposedly serving.

If a law exists to protect public safety, then its success ought to be measured by the harm it prevents.

Not by the amount of fucking money it collects.

In fact, if a traffic enforcement program genuinely succeeds in eliminating dangerous behavior, shouldn't its revenue eventually approach zero?

Wouldn't that be the desired outcome?

But when fines become part of the financial machinery of government, there's an obvious tension between eliminating violations and continuing to collect the money they generate.

And I don't think we should pretend that tension doesn't exist.

What the Fuck Is a Victimless Crime, Anyway?

Which brings me to a much larger question.

Why do we have so many laws criminalizing behavior that doesn't necessarily harm another person or their property?

I'm not arguing that dangerous conduct should be ignored until somebody ends up dead.

Threatening another person's safety can itself justify intervention. Reckless driving doesn't become acceptable simply because the driver happened to get lucky.

But there's a difference between demonstrably endangering another human being and violating a regulation that treats everybody as equally dangerous regardless of circumstances.

And somewhere along the way, we've lost sight of that distinction.

Our criminal codes are enormous. They're filled with prohibitions, technical violations, administrative offenses, and rules governing conduct that may never result in an identifiable victim.

I haven't done the math on what percentage falls into that category, and I'm not going to invent a fucking number.

But I think it's well past time we started asking whether every one of those prohibitions deserves to exist.

Because every law carries the threat of government force.

Every criminal prohibition gives government another reason to stop somebody, investigate somebody, accuse somebody, prosecute somebody, or punish somebody.

And every civil enforcement mechanism gives it another opportunity to reach into somebody's wallet.

That ought to make us cautious about creating laws.

Not enthusiastic about inventing new ways to enforce them.

Maybe We're Asking the Wrong Fucking Question

Whenever somebody questions speed limits, the conversation almost immediately turns into an argument about how fast people should be allowed to drive.

Seventy?

Eighty?

Eighty-five?

Ninety?

But maybe that's the wrong question.

Maybe we should be asking whether government needs to dictate a single maximum speed for every driver under every set of circumstances in the first place.

Maybe we should be asking why dangerous driving isn't the focus of traffic enforcement instead of simple numerical violations.

Maybe we should be asking why we're investing in automated systems designed to issue more fines instead of examining whether the underlying laws still make sense.

And maybe we should be asking whether a government that constantly expands its list of punishable offenses is actually making us safer.

Or simply making itself more powerful.

I'm not suggesting that speed no longer kills.

I'm not suggesting that speed no longer maims.

And I'm certainly not suggesting that driving a modern vehicle somehow exempts somebody from the laws of physics or their responsibility to other people.

I'm suggesting that speed alone is not the same thing as reckless driving.

And if our laws cannot distinguish between the two, perhaps the problem isn't the driver.

Perhaps the problem is the fucking law.

Because ultimately, I believe we need to start right-sizing our bloated criminal codes and eliminating prohibitions that cannot be justified by a legitimate need to protect people and their property.

Government shouldn't exist to police every possible deviation from somebody's preferred behavior.

It should exist to protect our rights.

And that brings me back to the question I started with.

Why the fuck do we still have so many speed limits?

Not because somebody at City Hall says we need them.

Not because a traffic engineer calculated a number decades ago.

And certainly not because government has discovered how convenient it is to turn a camera into a revenue-generating machine.

Give me an actual justification.

Show me the evidence.

Demonstrate that the restriction is necessary, proportionate, and genuinely effective.

Because the burden of justifying government power should rest with the government.

Not with the people who are supposed to be free.

Previous
Previous

Dear Fucking Cops: Stop Telling Me You Ride Too

Next
Next

Your Fucking Ordinance Doesn’t Trump the Constitution