You know, I used to live on the border. The other one.

I grew up near the Canadian border, where damn near everybody knew someone, or was related to someone, who worked for the Border Patrol. Nobody thought that was particularly controversial. We had a border. We had laws governing who could cross it. And we had people whose job was to enforce those laws. Pretty fucking straightforward.

When we heard about somebody being deported, the general reaction was that they probably shouldn't have been here illegally in the first place. Nobody treated the existence of immigration enforcement as some sort of constitutional crisis.

And yes, plenty of farmers where I grew up employed Mexican migrants who were in the country illegally during harvest season. Shame on them, I suppose. But they also hired locals willing to do the work. I honestly don't think it was always about finding the cheapest labor. I think a lot of those farmers were just trying to find enough warm bodies to get the fucking harvest in before the weather turned. I could be wrong, but I don't think I am.

Flash forward to today.

Holy fucking shit. My, how times have changed.

Apparently, we've reached the point where enforcing immigration law is itself considered an act of oppression. The self-appointed saviors of the downtrodden have descended upon the streets to protect the poor, helpless illegal alien.

(I imagine  someone clearing their throat, "Excuse me. I believe you mean undocumented migrant!"

Sure. That's what I fucking meant. Illegal alien.)

Look, immigration has always been part of the American story. My own family tree starts its American branches somewhere around the turn of the twentieth century, depending on whether you're following my mother's side or my father's. They came here, dealt with the immigration requirements of their time, and built lives in a country that offered opportunities they apparently thought were worth pursuing.

And that's the part I keep coming back to. People came here because America offered something worth having. Freedom. Opportunity. The chance to build a life. And becoming part of that country meant accepting that it had laws, including laws about immigration.

So how the fuck did we get from there to people physically blocking vehicles belonging to Immigration and Customs Enforcement?

I've seen videos of protesters obstructing ICE vehicles as agents try to leave their facilities and do their jobs. And I'm sitting here wondering when the simple concept of having immigration enforcement became so goddamn controversial.

Because here's a little detail that seems to have escaped some of these people.

We, the American people, created this fucking agency.

Not personally, obviously. I don't remember getting an invitation to the ribbon-cutting ceremony. But Congress created ICE in 2003 as part of the massive restructuring of federal agencies after September 11, 2001. The country had just experienced a catastrophic failure of national security, and Americans demanded that their government get its shit together.

So Congress reorganized the machinery of border security and immigration enforcement. ICE was one result.

And before ICE existed, other federal agencies performed those functions. Immigration enforcement didn't magically appear in 2003 because somebody in Washington woke up one morning and decided America needed a new collection of alphabet-soup bureaucrats.

We've had immigration laws and officials responsible for enforcing them for generations.

Now, does that mean ICE is beyond criticism? Of course not. It's a government agency, for fuck's sake. Government agencies screw things up. Sometimes spectacularly. If agents violate people's rights, abuse their authority, or ignore the law they're supposed to enforce, hold them accountable. I'll be right there demanding it.

But there's a pretty substantial difference between demanding accountability from law enforcement and deciding that law enforcement shouldn't be allowed to enforce the law at all.

And that's where some of these protests lose me.

You don't like the immigration laws? Fine. Work to change them. Petition Congress. Campaign for candidates who agree with you. Make your case to the American people. That's how a constitutional republic is supposed to work.

But physically obstructing federal officers because you don't like the laws they're enforcing? What the fuck do you think that accomplishes?

Those officers didn't write the immigration statutes. They didn't create the agency. They didn't personally invent the concept of a national border. They're employees of a government whose laws were enacted through the same political process everybody else gets to participate in.

And before somebody starts screaming that I'm demanding blind obedience to government, spare me. I've spent enough time criticizing government overreach to know the difference between legitimate authority and bureaucratic bullshit. A badge doesn't make somebody right, and a federal agency doesn't get a free pass just because Congress created it.

But the reverse is also true. The fact that you hate an agency doesn't automatically make everything it does illegitimate.

A functioning country has to be able to decide who enters, who stays, and what happens when those laws are violated. We can argue about how those decisions are made. We can argue about whether the laws are fair, whether enforcement priorities make sense, and whether the government is respecting people's rights.

Those are arguments worth having.

What I can't wrap my fucking head around is the idea that immigration enforcement itself has somehow become an intolerable concept.

Twenty-some years ago, Americans were demanding that Washington take border security and immigration enforcement more seriously. Congress responded by creating an agency specifically charged with carrying out those responsibilities.

And now we've got people standing in front of its vehicles, outraged that the agency is actually doing the job it was created to do.

You can criticize the methods. You can challenge the policies. You can demand better laws.

But if your entire argument boils down to being furious that immigration laws are being enforced, you're going to have to explain something to me.

What the fuck did you think ICE was created to do?

Make fucking snow cones?

Previous
Previous

The Qualified Idiot

Next
Next

Dear Fucking Cops: Stop Telling Me You Ride Too